BLOG

Meanwhile Use: Putting a Price on Real Estate’s In-Between

Thrive has launched 19 new Real Estate Metrics that put a value on the social impact of the built environment.

They cover new school, healthcare and community facilities, affordable homes, public realm, playgrounds, community gardens, access to gyms and swimming pools, walking and running tracks, low-carbon fit-out, workforce wellbeing and the meanwhile use of vacant property.

Together they give developers, investors and local authorities a common, evidence-based way to show what a scheme delivers for the people who live and work around it. This article takes a deep dive into one of them: the value of meanwhile use.

Every city has them: the shuttered shopping centre, the cleared site behind hoarding, the office block waiting for planning consent.

Between one use and the next, buildings can sit empty for months or years and that has costs. Vacant property costs owners in rates, security and insurance, and it costs places in footfall, safety and civic confidence.

Meanwhile use is the practice of filling that gap. Done well, it turns dead time into productive time. Yet for most of its history it has been treated as a nice-to-have rather than a serious asset strategy. Part of the reason for that is that no one had a reliable way to put a number on what it delivers.

What Meanwhile Use Is

Meanwhile use means occupying a property on a temporary basis while its long-term future is decided, funded or built. Leases typically run from a few months to a few years, often on flexible or reduced terms.

The occupiers are varied: charities, independent retailers testing a high street presence, galleries, community kitchens, event spaces and local makers. What they share is a need for affordable space and a willingness to work with uncertainty. Cleo Folkes, who leads Thrive’s real estate work, puts the case for activation plainly:

“While a development is sitting empty … that space is just sitting there and causing blight. You can actually activate that space, put something in temporary use … especially if you use it for community use, or open it up to SMEs.”

Cleo Folkes, Lead Consultant Real Assets, Thrive

For owners, the immediate benefits are well known. An occupied building is guarded, heated and maintained. Empty-property rates liabilities can fall. The asset stays visible and alive rather than becoming a magnet for decline.

For communities, meanwhile spaces often become anchors, bringing people back to streets that had started to empty.

Why Meanwhile Use Has Been Undervalued

Meanwhile use has rarely fitted into that language of numbers – yield, rent, capital value, void – that real estate investors are familiar with.

The rent it generates is usually low, sometimes nominal. Its real value sits elsewhere: in a street that looks cared for, and in jobs created, skills built, isolation reduced, streets made safer and local businesses given a first foothold. These outcomes are real, but they have been reported as case studies, photographs and anecdotes.

And so meanwhile schemes are approved as goodwill gestures, cut first when budgets tighten, and left out of the valuation conversation entirely. Without a figure, the benefit is invisible on the balance sheet.

Thrive’s Real Estate Metrics were built to change that. First, it helps to see what measurement looks like on a single building.

A Year in The Life of One Empty Building

Picture a building awaiting redevelopment. The owner agrees short term leases, and a small gallery and an event space move in:

  • At the end of the year, the owner records the units that were in meanwhile use, evidenced by documents it already holds: the agreements, the live development programme and a site plan. The gallery, which opened in July, counts for half the year. The following year the uses continue, and they are recorded again against the same definition and evidence, so each year’s figure can be compared with the last.
  • The owner opens the fenced forecourt of the site to the public for the life of the programme. That is new public realm, recorded by the square metre under its own Real Estate Metric, distinct from the fact that the units are occupied.
  • If part of the space becomes a temporary play area, that is a play facility, with its own metric too.
  • Some value sits outside the metrics altogether, such as events and training the occupiers run themselves, and a short year-end return from each occupier, covering activities run, people reached and months active, is the simplest way to capture what the owner cannot see.

Two buildings with an identical number of units in meanwhile use can create very different amounts of social value, and their reports will show it. Each layer carries its own value, which lets an owner see which uses add most at a given site and plan the next meanwhile programme on that basis.

And as well as a paragraph about a lively pop-up, the report can carry a record: two units, occupied for a combined 18 months, on a site with a live development programme.

Thrive’s Metric: A Financial Proxy for Meanwhile Use

That record becomes a value through Thrive’s meanwhile use metric, which expresses the reuse of vacant space in financial terms. Instead of asking owners to take social benefit on trust, it converts the outcome into a monetised figure that can sit alongside rent and void costs:

  • The metric is built on the Impact Evaluation Standard, the independently governed framework Thrive uses to measure social impact. This is aligned with HM Treasury’s Green Book, the basis used to appraise public spending. The claim is deliberately specific: what the metric captures is the fact that units at an asset awaiting development are back in productive use, valued as the difference an occupied unit makes to the households around it, which is why the public realm, the play area and the rest of the site’s value are recorded and valued separately.
  • In practice, that means a pop-up, a gallery or an event space can now be described not only by what it does but by what its return to use is worth: a defensible value, per year, that an owner can compare across a UK portfolio and over time, and roll up by asset, fund and year.
  • Every asset uses the same unit definition, evidence and pro-rating rule, so results from different teams and sites line up, and a figure for any asset in any year is available on request.
  • Data can be entered on the platform or brought in from existing property systems by API. Used at design stage, the metrics estimate what a scheme will create. In operation, they record what is delivered.

Cleo describes the result as “a social value passport over the whole asset lifecycle“.

What a Financial Proxy for Meanwhile Use Allows

A financial proxy does something case studies never could: it lets meanwhile use compete on equal terms.

  • For owners and developers, it reframes a vacant period from a cost to be minimised into an opportunity to create measurable value. Two options for the same empty unit, one left dark and one activated, can finally be compared in pounds. That is an argument an investment committee already accepts.
  • For investors, it supplies evidence for ESG and impact reporting that can withstand governance and assurance. A published figure can be traced to the leases and site records behind it.
  • For local authorities, it strengthens planning conversations. A developer who can show the monetised community benefit of a meanwhile phase brings more than promises to the table. Cleo has seen the appetite grow, noting “A lot of local authorities have become quite keen on meanwhile use.”
  • For occupiers, it shifts the power balance. A unit in community or small business use is shown to be worth something to the street around it, so its occupiers are no longer treated as grateful tenants on borrowed time.

Most importantly, it lets meanwhile use be planned rather than improvised. Once value can be forecast, it can be budgeted for, targeted and improved.

From Stopgap to Strategy

The empty building has always carried a hidden cost. Thrive’s metric makes the hidden benefit of filling it just as visible. That matters at a moment when high streets are being reimagined, office stock is being repurposed and every landlord is under pressure to show what their assets do for the places around them. Cleo puts the underlying challenge plainly:

“It’s always easy to estimate something … Actually measuring it, actually getting the data, is always harder … but the real value is in actually measuring the actual delivery.”

Cleo Folkes

Meanwhile use was never really temporary in its effects. The skills, businesses and connections it creates outlast the lease. Now the industry has a way to count the difference it makes to the place around it. When the in-between has a price, it stops being an afterthought and becomes part of the plan.

To see how meanwhile use and the other Real Estate Metrics work across an asset’s life, request a demo.

Q&A

What is meanwhile use in real estate?

Meanwhile use is the temporary occupation of a vacant building or site between one permanent use and the next. This is usually under a licence or short flexible lease at low or nominal rent. Common examples include pop-up retail, discounted workspace, community and cultural venues, temporary housing and activated open space.

Does meanwhile use count as social value?

Yes. Bringing vacant units back into productive use creates social value in itself. Meanwhile use can now be recorded through a dedicated place-based metric, claimed for each year the use continues and supported by evidence.

Does the meanwhile use metric cover everything that happens in a meanwhile space?

No. The meanwhile use metric records the reuse of vacant units at an asset awaiting development. Other value on the same site, such as new public realm or a play area, is measured under its own metrics. Activity run by occupiers, such as training or events, may create further value that sits outside the Real Estate Metrics.

How is social value measured in real estate?

Through place-based metrics that record the value a building or space delivers for each year it is in use, in proportion to how long the outcome ran, supported by evidence, rather than as one-off activities.

Why is real estate social value different from procurement social value?

Procurement social value is typically recorded as one-off deliverables, counted once. Real estate creates value continuously while an asset is in use, so real estate social value has to be measured annually across the asset’s operating life.

watch our video
Request a demo
Request a demo